A Lesbian’s Love for Man’s Best Friend
A (queer) personal essay about Sabrina Carpenter’s most recent album, Man’s Best Friend.

Sabrina Carpenter in A Nonsense Christmas on Netflix holding a garment bag labelled “FOR THE GAYS”
In August of this year, Sabrina Carpenter’s latest album had its one-year anniversary: Man’s Best Friend. The five foot blonde-haired pop star is often known for her pastel pin-up outfits, her clever playful lyrics, her infectious catchy tunes, and her raunchy themes. Last year, the buzz was around her “appealing to the male gaze” with her scandalous album cover, along with people concluding that her music was simply her expression of thorough disappointment with men while still being desperately horny for them regardless. Naturally, her target demographic largely consists of young adult heterosexual women. I, a non-binary lesbian, had Sabrina Carpenter as my top artist and was a top 0.06% global fan, as of December 2025
The first time that I sat down to listen to Sabrina Carpenter’s Man’s Best Friend album in 2026, I fell asleep. I seldom have success taking naps, and this one felt effortless. That day marked the first day that I had intentionally listened to an album from start to finish (or tried to, that is). What sparked this decision was me coming across a short Instagram video with the paraphrased caption “This song is so ABBA-coded!” with the closing song of Man’s Best Friend in the background, “Goodbye.” As soon as I heard the bouncy brass melody paired with Carpenter’s decadent harmonies, I was hooked. Naturally. I gave the whole song a listen, and all I wanted was more.
Once I finally listened to the album the whole way through, no one could shut me up about it. One of the people I badgered about the album to was my girlfriend at the time. After a week of begging her to listen and maybe a cry or two, she finally relented and gave it a listen. Nothing could have prepared me for her true thoughts and feelings; what she told me felt devastating to hear:
“Short n’ Sweet was better. I’ve never dated men, so it just didn’t vibe with me.”
Sabrina Carpenter performing “Espresso” at the 2024 MTV VMAs
For a moment, I just sat in silence over the phone. Did we listen to the same album? I thought to myself with irritated confusion. Did she not experience the ups and downs of the emotional ride that is Man’s Best Friend? For a moment, I had to stuff down my feelings and focus on the words she said, despite my belief that her opinions of this piece felt shallow.
While I hate to say it, the general public seems to agree on her first point. Sabrina Carpenter’s previous album, Short n’ Sweet, and her corresponding tour are what launched her into stardom. This album is what ultimately helped her go as far as to headline at Coachella this year.
For context on my ex’s second point, “I’ve never dated men,” needs some unpacking. We’re both lesbians, but I had dated a man in the past. In fact, the last person I had dated was a man; it was my longest lasting relationship ending two and a half years in. It would be disingenuous if I said that I had not once thought of him during the whole forty-two minutes of playtime. It definitely hurt hearing “I get wet at the thought of you / Being a responsible guy / Treating me like you’re supposed to do,” and knowing I’m guilty of saying it was hot when my ex-boyfriend brushed his teeth. So, perhaps she has a point, right? Not only was that relationship with a man quite recent at the time, but plenty of the songs I really related to correlated with my feelings about him and how unfulfilled, unloved, and disappointed I was.
My heart sank when I heard her true thoughts and opinions on the album. Not just because it was sad that she didn’t like the thing that I have dedicated an embarrassing amount of hours listening to, but because it felt like a reductive conclusion and analysis of the music. Even before deeper analysis of the contents of the album, I knew that the core experience of Man’s Best Friend wasn’t as simple as what it’s like dating men. At that moment, I just couldn’t articulate it.

Sabrina Carpenter in her Manchild music video.
The album starting with “Manchild” may not be a good support on that front. With the song’s messaging screaming the incompetence and stupidity of the men that Carpenter’s dealt with, it’s definitely an example that proved my ex’s point to a T. However, my girlfriend said that “Manchild” was one of the highlight tracks of the album, like she could “hop on the man-hating train” with no problems.
So, what was really her problem here?
I ended up pressing her more on the true reason that she felt the album fell flat for her. Maybe there was some other reason it felt unrelatable or some other gripe she had. After a long while, she admitted to me that she was scared that she was “the kind of person Sabrina is singing about” in her previous relationship. She told me that listening to the album made her upset and sad. I thought to myself, that’s not a bad thing; I’ve cried while listening to My Man on Willpower at least thrice! I tried my best to reassure her that she didn’t need to feel insecure, and I was sure that she wasn’t as bad as all those guys Sabrina sings about. At the time, we had been together for about three months. But perhaps I, at 20-years-old, didn’t get the full scope of what really happened during her 6-year-long marriage and divorce. I suppose it should’ve been a sign that when I listened, I felt seen; when she listened, she felt guilt.
I will not try to make the argument that this album is or isn’t male-centered (if I did, this would be a much longer essay). Even still, I will die on the hill that enjoying this album is not simply about one’s gendered dating experiences. This album is also about how one is treated in a relationship and what it does to someone’s feelings during and after it. As much as I’d like to also jump on the man-hating train, so many of the things Sabrina Carpenter talks about in her songs are things that anyone can experience from anyone.
It’s always a delight to get to listen to music from queer artists about their experiences in relationships, both unique and common ones. With all the difficulties and the world of hatred that queer people have to survive against, it makes sense that there are a lot more queer love songs than heartbreak songs. I can see duality like this show through The Rise and Fall of a Midwest Princess by Chappell Roan just as much as I still can see myself within Man’s Best Friend. While some love songs can feel gender-specific, it would be a lie to say all the experiences Carpenter expresses in her music are limited to cisgender-heterosexual women exclusively.

Sabrina Carpenter and Chappell Roan singing Last Christmas by Wham! together in A Nonsense Christmas.
Contrasting Short n’ Sweet, Man’s Best Friend is an album arranged to be listened to in order. Despite that, the stories that are told throughout it aren’t linear. In each track, Carpenter pokes a little fun at herself or her situation to varying degrees. However, the songs that I love the most are the ones that have themes that may not click on the first listen. I can fully understand why “House Tour” and “Go Go Juice” are higher on the charts with their playful lyrics, fun energy, and Carpenter’s signature clever charm. However, the tracks that made me falter and reflect are the ones that drew me in and make me fall for this album every time I listen to it.
It takes a lot of self restraint and control to stop myself from gushing about each track that makes a shiver run down my spine when I let myself truly hear her music and listen to her words. No one seems to paint the picture of being desperate for the bare minimum of functionality in a partner the way that Sabrina does. No one seems to describe the authentic ways one must process and handle their own feelings and standards the way Sabrina does. No one can manage these themes in such funny ways that Sabrina always does.
The best song of hers to demonstrate that feeling was released on streaming months after the album’s release, a bonus track titled “Such A Funny Way.” The song opens only with soft percussion interrupted by soft rhythmic snaps. After six measures, the quiet synths and vocals begin:
“Must be that you want me so much that you don’t have the words
Keep me far from friends and family, baby, that’s just one of your quirks
And if distance makes you fonder, I’m flattered by the distance you seek
And you know just how to thrill me
Oh honey, how you kill me”
“You have such a funny way of sayin’ “I love you””
This song had me in a chokehold far beyond my original favorite, “Goodbye,” ever did. The jaunty shifts in tempo and additions of brass and woodwinds throughout the song certainly make it stand out against the album. The lyrical nod to ABBA’s “Honey Honey” at the end of the first verse was the perfect cherry on top of this track. What stuck out to me the most was the bridge right before the end of the song.
“It’s funny you’re out drinkin’, funny I’m at home
Funny everybody knows something that I don’t
Funny how I do this every single time
So funny that I have to laugh
just so I don’t cry”

Sabrina Carpenter’s instagram post in September 2025 announcing the bonus track, Such a Funny Way
Giving the song a listen awakened feelings in me that I didn’t realize I had about being lost in a relationship; how on Earth can I cope with feeling so unloved?
The foreshadowing of my ex-girlfriend’s disconnect from the album was unfortunately a reflection of our downfall and our eventual disconnect (note to readers: I’m not saying that if listening to this album makes you think of your current partner that you should break up, but I’m not not saying that). It’s undeniable that issues in straight relationships have been normalized (weaponized incompetence, “I hate my wife” rhetoric), but as much as I’d like to scapegoat heterosexuality and jump on the man-hating train, disappointment can come from anywhere and anyone. Whether or not her disliking of the album was because of guilt, insecurity, or truly a misunderstanding of the art is something that shall remain unknown to me and to all. However, if it’s the latter, perhaps it didn’t land due to her experiences not aligning with Sabrina’s themes and experiences.
And that’s okay.
I have yet to meet another queer person quite as passionate about Man’s Best Friend as me, but I firmly believe that there are more out there who already do; perhaps there are queers I just haven’t had the chance to convert yet. My current girlfriend is subjected to my obsession (still going strong [both the relationship and my obsession with this album]) and is happy to listen to any of my vinyl records front to back whenever the desire may strike me. It is undeniable that I’m not the target demographic for Sabrina’s music, but I will scream until my face turns blue that this album is one not just for straight girls; this album is for anyone who has ever felt lost, ignored, or unseen in love. And lastly, this album is undoubtedly for ABBA fans, obviously.

